Evolution, the Human Brain, and the Need for Community

Aristotle once wrote: “Man is by nature a social animal […] Anyone who either cannot lead the common life or is so self-sufficient as not to need to, and therefore does not partake of society, is either a beast or a god.” A new book by leading social psychologist and neuroscientist Matthew Lieberman, reviewed in an article in the Atlantic magazine, presents a modern version of the same argument. Drawing on a wide range of research studies in psychology and neuroscience, Lieberman makes the case that the human brain is literally wired for social interaction and belonging. It’s worth reading in full, but here are some exceptionally interesting excerpts:

One of the great mysteries of evolutionary science is how and why the human brain got to be so large. […] Scientists have debated this question for a long time, but the research of anthropologist Robin Dunbar is fairly conclusive on this point. Dunbar has found that the strongest predictor of a species’ brain size – specifically, the size of its neocortex, the outermost layer – is the size of its social group. We have big brains in order to socialize.

So it’s safe to say that the human brain did not evolve to be such a powerful and hyper-complex organ in order to just sit around alone and twiddle one’s thumbs. Ever since the dawn of time, the trend has been for humans to develop more and more complex social systems, and ever larger brains to go with them. The synergy that results from harmonious social relations is clearly an evolutionary advantage.

When economists put a price tag on our relationships, we get a concrete sense of just how valuable our social connections are – and how devastating it is when they are broken. If you volunteer at least once a week, the increase to your happiness is like moving from a yearly income of $20,000 to $75,000. If you have a friend that you see on most days, it’s like earning $100,000 more each year. Simply seeing your neighbors on a regular basis is said to increase your happiness “income” $60,000 a year more. On the other hand, when you break a critical social tie – here, in the case of getting divorced – it’s like suffering a $90,000 per year decrease in your income.

The exact figures here can be debated, but the broader point is still valid: our social connections generally make us happier. There has long been a great wealth of research linking social support to better outcomes, both physical and mental, but putting a monetary figure on the happiness produced by our relationships is a really striking way to demonstrate this dynamic.

To the brain, social pain feels a lot like physical pain – a broken heart can feel like a broken leg, as Lieberman puts it in his book. […] A broken leg and a broken heart seem like very different forms of pain. But there are evolutionary reasons why our brains process social pain the way they process physical pain. Pain is a sign that something is wrong. Social pain signals that we are all alone – that we are vulnerable – and need to either form new connections or rekindle old ones to protect ourselves against the many threats that are out there.

We put up psychological defenses and pretend we can be just fine on our own, but our very neurobiology compels us to seek and maintain the company of others. This research also shows that the mental pain of isolation, loneliness and depression, which affect so many seniors with mobility issues, is every bit as real and devastating as physical pain. The aging process is not a “threat” but it does come with many challenges, and intentional aging in community is a fun and intelligent way to manage those challenges with the companionship of others, just the way nature intended.

Wednesday, November 20: Successful Aging Orientation Workshop

We are pleased to announce that we will be sponsoring our second Successful Aging Orientation on the 20th at 6:30 pm. This class lead by Elders Village will establish the need for education and training on aging issues, provide an overview of the entire course curriculum and examine the rationale for emphasizing community throughout the course. Please come join us for this exciting and insightful course.

Elders Village Talk on Safety Coming Up on Nov. 6th

Elders Village, a non-profit dedicated to educating seniors, hosts an ongoing monthly series of talks on various topics of interest to older adults. This month, the Elders Village Talk on Safety will be held at the Alameda Elks Lodge (2555 Santa Clara Ave.) on Wednesday, November 6th at 6:30 pm.

There will be a panel of experts discussing Senior Safety:

  • Dena Aindow, Alameda County District Attorney’s office, will discuss scams and fraud
  • Capt. Michael DeGrano, Alameda Fire Department, will discuss disaster preparedness
  • Dale Woolley, DPT, Alameda Elder Services, will discuss home and physical safety

The Elders Village Talks are free and open to the public, so grab your friends and come learn all about senior safety! To ensure a seat at the event, please RSVP at 510-217-8527. Be safe, everyone!

Aging and Community: A Natural Fit

The Santa Rosa Press Democrat recently ran a story about a small cohousing community in Mendocino County (California) named Cheesecake (the article originally appeared in the New York Times). Besides its endearing name and secluded, wooded environment, one of the most striking aspects of the community is how the members have learned to deal with the issues of aging and care.

Cheesecake wasn’t formed with aging in place as a primary concern. The original 11 members were simply a mix of married couples and single women in their fifties and sixties who wanted to live a cooperative lifestyle far from the city. The community even decided initially that anyone who became seriously ill would have to leave, since “Cheesecake wasn’t designed to function as a hospital or hospice.” Yet as the members became older and started requiring more care, the community re-examined its thinking:

When Dick Browning, a retired school principal, brought his wife back after her 2003 surgery, residents began appearing at the Brownings’ door within the hour, he said: “They asked, ‘Can I be the one to bring tea to you?’ ‘Can I bring flowers every day?’ ” […] Cheesecake was envisioned for happier times, but for some of its residents it also seems to have made the difficult ones more bearable.

The Successful Aging workshop series led by Elders Village (and sponsored by Phoenix Commons) explains the benefits of proximity and intention while aging, which allow neighbors to provide the much needed social and moral support, while professional caregivers can be hired at affordable group rates to do the heavy lifting. This is not only theory; there are numerous examples of this approach leading to optimal aging and healing, and it looks like the Cheesecake community have figured this out on their own. The genius of cooperative aging, and the attractiveness of intentional communities like Cheesecake and Phoenix Commons, is perhaps most simply stated in the article: “No one should have to grow old alone.”

For more information on how to age successfully through community, please contact Elders Village and ask about the Successful Aging course: (510) 217-8527. A complimentary course orientation workshop is being held this Thursday (Oct. 24th, 6:30-8:30 pm), so call or email now to reserve your spot!

Phoenix Commons officially a 55+ Community

We have just received word that the City of Oakland has agreed to change the age restriction from 60 to 55, in order to conform with federal fair housing laws. This is great news for future community members under the age of 60, who would have faced exclusion from Phoenix Commons if not for the expeditious and reasonable approach taken by Oakland’s city planners. The city’s ongoing enthusiastic cooperation with Phoenix Commons is much appreciated, and provides even more proof that Oakland is truly a hot spot for forward-thinking and community-minded people from all walks of life!

Thursday, October 24: Successful Aging Orientation Workshop

We are pleased to announce that we will be sponsoring our first Successful Aging Orientation on the 24th at 6:30 pm. This class lead by Elders Village will establish the need for education and training on aging issues, provide an overview of the entire course curriculum and examine the rationale for emphasizing community throughout the course. Please come join us for this exciting and insightful course.

Thursday, October 17: Workshop on Ecology and Legacy.

On the 17th at 6:30 pm we will be hosting the final module of the Successful Aging series- Aging, Ecology and Legacy. This class lead by Elders Village will cover the how to see ecology as a study of relationships both between yourself, society and nature, ways in which our ecological concepts change as we age and understanding the legacy as a positive contribution for future generations. If you are interested in joining in the Successful Aging Workshop series please call us about attending (510-217-8527) one of the Successful Aging Orientations, the next orientation will be held on October 24th at 6:30 pm.

Senior Cooperative Living: University-Style

The ASA (American Society on Aging) blog has a fascinating interview with USC professor Victor Regnier, who holds the country’s only joint appointment to an architecture school and school of gerontology. His architectural grad students have designed a community based on the Apartment for Life housing projects that are popular in Europe, particularly the Netherlands. Just as in the cohousing concept, Apartment for Life residents can arrange for specific services when they need them, thus eliminating the problem of overcare experienced by so many seniors in assisted living facilities.

In the article, Prof. Regnier also mentions the cooperation of a developer with housing experience and a health care provider with gerontological experience as an ideal arrangement for such projects. This is a strong endorsement of Phoenix Commons’ philosophy, as it has been designed by Alameda Elder Communities, which has over 40 years of experience in senior housing and health care, and the community’s members will continue to be able to count on AEC’s expertise and support whenever needed. With senior cooperative lifestyle communities such as Phoenix Commons,  Wolf Creek Lodge, and USC’s proposed Apartment for Life gaining ever greater awareness in the general public, older adults can look forward to better housing and care options that respect their autonomy and dignity.

 

Tuesday, October 17: Workshop on Identity and Spirituality.

On the 17th at 6:30 pm we will be hosting the fifth module of the Successful Aging series- Identity and Spirituality. This class lead by Elders Village will cover the effects of aging on your self and social identities, personal and social aspects of the fear of aging and how to accept aging as a vehicle for personal and spiritual growth. If you are interested in joining in the Successful Aging Workshop series please call us about attending (510-217-8527) one of the Successful Aging Orientations, the next orientation will be held on October 24th at 6:30 pm.

Thursday, October 15: Workshop on Lifestyle and Finances

On the 15th at 6:30 pm we will be hosting the fourth module of the Successful Aging series- Lifestyle and Finances. This class lead by Elders Village will cover the expenses and savings associated with aging, various options for living an affordable lifestyle as you age and understand how community can increase the quality of life on a fixed budget. If you are interested in joining in the Successful Aging Workshop series please call us about attending (510-217-8527) one of the Successful Aging Orientations, the next orientation will be held on October 24th at 6:30 pm.